Why did the people stormed the Bastille and how of import was the storming to the start of the revolution?

The Gallic Revolution in 1789 changed France and “equalized” the rights of the people. One of the major events that started it was the storming of the Bastille on July 14th. 1789. This twenty-four hours represented the Gallic revolution because it showed us the public’s sprit of rebellion. Rumors were everyplace during that period of clip and hence. most people were able to hear of the horrific and secret Bastille. In world. the Bastille was non every bit atrocious as all the rumours and pictures had described. Are the rumours the ground the people stormed the Bastille? Was the storming of the Bastille important to the Gallic revolution? In fact. there were a few grounds that contributed to the storming of the Bastille and they showed the importance of it to the start of the revolution.

The Bastille was a immense construction situated in the East of Paris. ( Source 6 ) It was a prison built in the fourteenth century to guard Paris. but by the eighteenth century. the Bastille had become a prison. Throughout the eighteenth century. there were ne’er more than 40 captives. and most of them were served with short sentences. On July 14. 1789. during the storming of the Bastille. there were merely 7 captives and two of them were insane. But to most people in 1789. the Bastille was a drab chilling topographic point. Why do the people think that manner? To the writers. sculpturers and painters who glorified the pickings of the Bastille. it was a dark and secret palace that captives will ne’er return. ( Source 3 ) Besides. people heard of atrocious experiences and lives in the Bastille. such as hungering. utmost coldness. tormenting etc. Therefore. writers and creative persons drew. write and sculpt about what they think the scary and secret prison. For art plants. a celebrated representative will be the Bastille in Paris by Jean-Pierre Houel ( Source 1 ) . and it showed the darkness of the tormenting prison.

As for eyewitness history. Constantine de Renneville. a in-between category revenue enhancement functionary who was incarcerated in 1702. wrote the verse form “The Bastille as a Symbol of Tyranny” . He said that he suffered in the Bastille and he sleeps with rats on moist straw. eat merely bread and H2O. and was exposed to extreme cold. ( Source 2 ) These art plants and paragraphs were dispersed widely to the society and rumour started distributing over Paris. There will non be any manner we could see the truth of the events. but I suspect he was distributing bogus rumours about the Bastille for the male monarch to fear the people. as modern historiographers already proved the rumours were used to fear people. A batch of historiographers think that the rumours are the ground why the Parisians stormed the Bastille because these rumours showed people the king’s control. Therefore. they hated the Bastille. as it symbolized the king’s power. ( Source 4 )

On the other manus. some historiographers like George Rude claimed the ground for the storming of the Bastille was because people saw military personnels of the foreign states. and thought Louis XVI was traveling to assail Paris with the aid of foreign ground forcess. Rude stated in his book The Gallic Revolution “The immediate purpose was to happen the pulverization which had been sent at that place from the arsenal…” he claimed that the Parisians did non take to ramp the Bastille at first. and planned to negociate with the authorities. All they wanted was the gunpowder to support themselves. Rude besides claimed “It was rumored that during the dark military personnels had marched into Faubourg …begun to butcher its citizens. ” And hence. the people were frightened and decided to take the gunpowder to support against the foreign military personnels. ( Source 8 )

No affair the grounds why the Bastille got stormed. modern historiographers have strong argument against how important the storming of Bastille was. A history instructor Miss Lavelle claimed the soldiers refused to halt the storming by assailing their ain country’s citizen was a symbol of the male monarch lost control of the Gallic ground forces ( beginning 7 ) . hence. a batch of historiographers such as Robert W. Brown ( beginning 5 ) . Barry Vale that wrote the article “Bastille stormed 1789” and Lavelle think the storming of the Bastille is highly important as the start of the Gallic Revolution. since the revolution was to get rid of the king’s power. Besides. Bastille Day is a national vacation of France and originated from the Storming of the Bastille on July 14th. This. to me. indicates that most people will hold that the storming of the Bastille was of import. because there are even day of remembrances for the event to retrieve people from the Gallic Revolution.

On the other side. historiographers like _Steven Kreis_ and Sally Waller think that the storming of Bastille was non the start of the Gallic revolution. Kreis didn’t even advert the Bastille and to me. it indicates that he doesn’t believe it was important as the start of the Gallic revolution at all. While on the other manus. Waller mentioned the Bastille. but she clearly stated that she thinks the start of the revolution was the naming of the estate generals and tennis tribunal curse. while the storming of the Bastille that happened on July 14th. 1789 was what developed from the eruption of the Gallic revolution.

As for beginning 4. the rabble were angry because the governor did non return when they asked him for the permission to acquire into ammo for the gunpowder. It indicates that the storming of the Bastille is non of import to the start of the revolution because the people stormed the Bastille merely to protect themselves. non because they wanted to get rid of the king’s power. At the same clip. beginning 6 stated that ironically. on July 14th. Louis Sixteen in the comfort of his castle. he was unaware of the event go oning. he wrote nil on his journal for the twenty-four hours. This shows that. to Louis XVI. and some people at that period of clip. the storming of the Bastille was nil and non of import at all. and hence. it supports some historians’ point. that the storming of the Bastille was non of import to the start of the revolution.

I personally think that both the rumours of the Bastille that made people hated the Bastille. and the fright of the people due to the foreign military personnels contributed to the storming of the Bastille. Because. the beginnings indicates that due to the low intelligence degree of the people during the period of clip compared to presents. and with an extra influence of their hungriness. they could hold believed in the rumours blindly to “save” themselves from hungering. Therefore I think they most likely attacked the Bastille because they hated it as a symbol of the king’s power. On the other manus. as they were frightened when the foreign military personnels marched into the metropolis. they most likely were nervous and would desire to happen a manner to support themselves. Plus. the governor didn’t return when the crowd was inquiring for the gunpowder. so they were even more disquieted and that’s why they stormed the Bastille.

Therefore. I think that both of the position contributed to the storming of the Bastille. As for the start of the Gallic revolution. I agree that the storming of the Bastille is significantly of import to the start of the Gallic revolution. The Gallic revolution started because the people wanted equality and wanted to get rid of the king’s power. and the storming of the Bastille made the male monarch lost his control of the Gallic ground forces. It is the start of the male monarch losing his power. and after the storming of Bastille. events started to go on and the male monarch started to lose his power easy. As the storming of Bastille became one of the most celebrated events in the history and was assigned as the national vacation of France afterwards. it besides shows the importance of the storming of the Bastille as the start of the Gallic revolution. And hence. I agree that it was highly important to the start of the Gallic revolution.

We do non hold a opportunity to see what precisely happened during on July 14th. 1789. but I see no uncertainty on the significance of the storming of the Bastille and how it is the symbol of Gallic Revolution. because that was how people “took over” the king’s power. as they was in control of the symbol of king’s power. the Bastille.

Beginning 1:

Early prisons were dark. dour topographic points designed for anguish and punitory parturiency. as depicted in this picture of the Bastille in Paris by Jean-Pierre Houel. Officials did non anticipate captives to return to society and made no effort to rehabilitate them.

Beginning: This picture is painted by Jean-Pierre Houel

Purpose: This beginning is a painting picturing the Bastille in Paris.

Value: Paintings are sometimes dependable because they can efficaciously capture the spirit of a clip. This beginning besides contains grounds about the Bastille. and even if it is non true. it provides us with illustration of art manners of the clip. Besides. this picture can demo how Jean-Pierre Houel felt about the Bastille and supply us with his sentiment. As Jean-Pierre Houel lives during the same period of clip. this beginning will be a primary beginning. Primary beginning are sometime more dependable compared to secondary beginning. because they get first manus information on the events. Therefore. this makes the beginning rather dependable.

Restrictions: By looking at the restrictions of the beginning. we could happen a batch of possibilities that might impact the truth of the beginning. Paintings are produced by an creative person with his ain definite point of position. hence. this beginning is biased. as it is affected by Jean-Pierre Houel’s point of position and sentiments. Besides. this peculiar picture is a limited beginning because

it merely describe one facet of the event. As creative persons are non by and large concerned with supplying an history of historical event. the beginning will be more emotional and artistic instead than historically entering the inside informations of the Bastille. This causes the beginning to be less dependable. Besides. creative persons drew the pictures to sell. hence. they have to do the picture artistic and nice. When they do it. they might lose out some important inside informations of the Bastille. this besides will do the beginning less accurate. Therefore. this beginning might non be that dependable. missing a batch of truth.

Jean-Pierre Houel. _The Bastille in Paris_ .

Beginning 2:

The Bastille as a Symbol of Tyranny

Persons. be frightened by this image of snake pit. A autocrat regulations here. the Satan is his slave. For Satan punishes merely the guilty. But Bernaville may cut down Innocence herself.

“Under an gap in the wall. I saw human castanetss ; it was like a graveyard. and since I found the basement in parts without paving. I dug and found a cadaver wrapped in shred. . . the warder said that they had kept the sorry remains in his cell ; two other work forces and one adult female had suffered the same destiny. ”

This verse form accompanied an history of the Bastille by Constantine de Renneville. a in-between category revenue enhancement functionary who was incarcerated in 1702 for
descrying for the Dutch authorities.

Beginning: This is a verse form and a transition by Constantine de Renneville. a in-between category revenue enhancement functionary who was incarcerated in 1702 for descrying for the Dutch authorities.

Purpose: The intent of Constantine de Renneville is non clearly stated. It might be stating people how tough his life in the Bastille was.

Value: The beginning is written by Constantine de Renneville. which is an eyewitness history of the Bastille. because he was even imprisoned in the Bastille. This makes the beginning seems dependable as he experienced the life in the Bastille. This beginning chronicles the experiences and feelings of Renneville and offers an emotional entreaty. leting readers to place closely. This provides us with at least Renneville’s sentiment on the Bastille. Therefore. this beginning is valuable. by and large dependable but lack affirmatory truth.

Restriction: As the male monarchs want people to fear him. he might order Renneville to distribute rumour on the atrocious life in Bastille when he came out. This possibility makes the beginning inaccurate because if so. so Renneville will be concealing the fact. Besides. as it is written by one person. there might be bias and might be affected by his ain sentiment and feeling. Therefore. the beginning might miss truth and will non be excessively dependable for this peculiar inquiry.

Beginning 3:

“The Bastille was a prison. built of rock. it had eight unit of ammunition towers. with it”s highest tower being 73 pess. It was built as a defensive garrison against the British. and was non converted into a prison until under the regulation of Charles VI. TO THE AUTHORS. SCULPTORS AND PAINTERS WHO GLORIFIED THE TAKING OF THE BASTILLE. IT WAS A DARK AND SECRET CASTLE. WHERE PRISONERS NEVER RETURNED FROM. EACH PRISONER HUNG FROM SHACKLES UNTIL THEIR DRIED BONES WERE PUSHED INTO A CORNER. BUT THE BASTILLE WAS Nothing LIKE THAT IN REALITY.

It was a prison for aristocracy. clergy. the occasional disgraceful writer. and juvenile delinquents whose parents had asked for them to be kept at that place. Most captives had more money spent on them. so it took for an mean Parisian to exist. The life quarters were octangular suites. 16 pess in diameter. Pets were allowed to cover with the varmint. and captives were allowed trappingss. apparels. and other personal properties. Even one of the most ill-famed felons. the brainsick Marquis de Sade. made his place their. having his married woman and other visitants on a regular footing. ”

“Essay on World History. College Papers. Research Papers on The Reign of Terror and the Gallic Revolution. ” _Dream Essaies: Custom Term Paper and Essay Writing Firm_ . Web. 28 Sept. 2009. .

Beginning: This is a secondary beginning. An essay/Term paper on the reign of panic and the Gallic revolution.

Purpose: The intent of this beginning is for instruction. It is a beginning to learn people. so it is

instead dependable and there shouldn’t be bias because educational beginnings are suppose to be impartial.

Value: It is educational beginnings so there won’t be bias and hence it’s dependable. It is instead dependable because it is a term paper and if it is non accurate plenty. Markss will be deducted. As this secondary beginning is written long clip after the event. there will be a batch of available beginnings and might assist to do the paper more accurate. Therefore. this beginning should be by and large dependable.

Restriction: It is counted as a secondary beginning because it isn’t an eyewitness beginning. but it doesn’t average it is non dependable if it’s a secondary beginning. Secondary beginning might be incorrect because as clip passed. information alterations and if it’s verbally passed from coevalss to coevalss. so it might non be every bit accurate as it was. Therefore. I think this beginning is largely dependable. but non wholly dependable.

Beginning 4:

“When captives were released from the walls of the Bastille. they were allowed to travel merely if they agreed ne’er to state what they had seen or what had happened inside the feared prison. This deficiency of cognition about the Bastille helped to make a mystique of horror and panic that the King could utilize to hale certain things out of people. However. the world of the Bastille was much different than the mystique created by the King. All of the suites until the twelvemonth 1701 were left unfurnished. Affluent political captives were allowed to convey in their ain furniture. many even brought their ain retainers with them. Meals were of generous proportions. and more epicurean repasts could be bought if the captive was affluent plenty. Most captives were docile. They were allowed to walk freely around the fortress. talk with officers and other captives and play games. Many had their ain personal avocations. and a few were even allowed to see the metropolis of Paris on word. The Bastille was much more comfy. even homelike. than the hideous rumours that circled around France proclaimed. ”

Smith. Brian. “History of the Bastille. ” _Essortment Articles: Free Online Articles on Health. Science. Education & A ; More. . _ 2002. Web. 18 Sept. 2009. .

Beginning: This is a secondary beginning. It is a brief sum-up of the history of the Bastille.

Purpose: The intent of this beginning is for instruction. As its intent is to educate people. it will be instead dependable and there shouldn’t be bias because educational beginnings are suppose to be impartial.

Value: It is educational beginnings so there won’t be bias and hence it’s dependable. As this secondary beginning is written long clip after the event. there will be a batch of available beginnings and might assist to do the paper more accurate. Therefore. this beginning should be by and large dependable.

Restriction: It is counted as a secondary beginning because it isn’t an eyewitness beginning. but it doesn’t average it is non dependable if it’s a secondary beginning. Secondary beginning might be incorrect because as clip passed. information alterations and if it’s verbally passed from coevalss to coevalss. so it might non be every bit accurate as it was. Therefore. I think this beginning should be instead dependable. missing some truth.

Beginning 5:

Brown. Robert W. “The French Revolution. ” _T he University of North Carolina at Pembroke_ . Web. 26 Sept. 2009. .

( The ground I chose this: Please mention to beginning 4’s analysis value. )

Beginning 6:

An dry find that was made was the entry in King Louis XVI’s journal for that peculiar day of the month. In the comfort of his Palace at the Versailles he was unaware of the impact of the events that were taking topographic point in Paris and the effects that they would hold on the future class of the country’s destiny he wrote “July 14th ; nothing” .

“French Revolution Ramping the Bastille. ” _Translation Services | Interpreters | Intercultural Communication | Cross Cultural Training_ . Web. 28 Sept. 2009. .

( The ground I chose this: Please mention to beginning 4’s analysis value. )

Beginning 7:

Lavelle. “The Revolution Begins. ” _SchoolHistory. co. uk – online history
lessons. alteration. games. worksheets. quizzes and links. _ Web. 22 Sept. 2009. .

( The ground I chose this: Please mention to beginning 4’s analysis value. )

Beginning 8:

Monarchist historiographers have scoffed at the image of 1000s of Parisians hurtling themselves at the Bastille to let go of a smattering of captives. But such unfavorable judgment falls slightly broad of the grade. The immediate purpose was to happen the pulverization which had been sent at that place from the arsenal – all the more pressing after the big draw of muskets taken from the Invalids. Other motives no uncertainty played a portion. It was believed that the fortress was to a great extent manned ; its guns. which that forenoon were trained on the Rue St Antoine. could play mayhem among the crowded tenements ; besides. it was rumored that during the dark military personnels had marched into the Faubourg and had already begun to butcher its citizens. Furthermore. though it had ceased to harbor more than a tickle of province captives. the Bastille was widely hated as a simple of ministerial absolutism.

Rude. George. _The Gallic Revolution_ . New York: Grove. Print. ( pg 54 )

( The ground I chose this: Please mention to beginning 4’s analysis value. )

Beginning 9:

Kreis. Steven. “Lecture 11: The Origins of the Gallic Revolution. ” _The History Guide — Main_ . 2000. Web. 28 Sept. 2009. .

( The ground I chose this: Please mention to beginning 4’s analysis value. )

Beginning 10:

FRANCE IN REVOLUTION. 1776-1830 By Sally Waller

Waller. Sally. _Heinemann Advanced History_ . New York: Heinemann Educational. 2002. Print.

( The ground I chose this: Please mention to beginning 4’s analysis value. )

Bibliography

Brown. Robert W. “The French Revolution. ” _The University of North Carolina at Pembroke_ . Web. 26 Sept. 2009. .

“Essay on World History. College Papers. Research Papers on The Reign of Terror and the Gallic Revolution. ” _Dream Essaies: Custom Term Paper and Essay Writing Firm_ . Web. 28 Sept. 2009. .

“French Revolution Ramping the Bastille. ” _Translation Services | Interpreters | Intercultural Communication | Cross Cultural Training_ . Web. 28 Sept. 2009. .

Jean-Pierre Houel. _The Bastille in Paris_ .

Kreis. Steven. “Lecture 11: The Origins of the Gallic Revolution. ” _The History Guide — Main_ . 2000. Web. 28 Sept. 2009. .

Lavelle. “The Revolution Begins. ” _SchoolHistory. co. uk – online history lessons. alteration. games. worksheets. quizzes and links. _ Web. 22 Sept. 2009. .

Rude. George. _The Gallic Revolution_ . New York: Grove. Print.

Smith. Brian. “History of the Bastille. ” _Essortment Articles: Free Online Articles on Health. Science. Education & A ; More. . _ 2002. Web. 28 Sept. 2009. .

Waller. Sally. _Heinemann Advanced History_ . New York: Heinemann Educational. 2002. Print.

Categories: Essay